California AG: Meta Trial Not About Damages, But Restitution
Key Points
- California AG Rob Bonta stated Tuesday the Meta trial centers on civil penalties, restitution, and distortion, not damages.
- A bipartisan group of 29 attorneys general from states including California, Colorado, New Jersey, and Kentucky are co-leading the case against Meta.
- State lawyers are seeking significant civil penalties and want Meta to delete all personal data for children under 13, including related algorithms.
States' Legal Strategy and Remedies Sought
California Deputy Attorney General Megan O'Neill opened the case by accusing Meta of a coordinated deception campaign. "Meta, one of the largest, most powerful companies in the world, carried out a campaign to deceive, to mislead its users, legislatures, teachers and parents," O'Neill told the eight-member advisory jury during opening arguments. She alleged that public statements by executives, including CEO Mark Zuckerberg, contradicted the company's internal research into child mental health impacts.
Read Next
Apple Cuts EU App Store Fees to 5% for Third-Party Stores
11 hours ago
Nvidia Shifts AI Dominance Strategy: $105 Billion OpenAI Data Center Investment
19 hours ago
The states are seeking far more than financial penalties. Attorneys representing the 29 states want Meta to delete all personal data collected from children under 13 and eliminate the algorithms and models trained using that information. They also demand removal of specific design features including infinite scroll, autoplay, and beauty filters that prosecutors argue are engineered to maximize user engagement.
Paul Schmidt, a trial attorney representing Meta at Covington & Burling, disputed O'Neill's characterization during his opening statement, asking the jury to examine whether the evidence actually supports the states' specific claims about executive misconduct.
Related coverage: Apple Cuts EU App Store Fees to 5% for Third-Party Stores
The lawsuit was filed in 2023 and stems from allegations that Meta violated the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) and various state consumer protection statutes. Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers will ultimately decide Meta's fate, with the advisory jury playing an advisory role—the same structure used in the Elon Musk versus Sam Altman trial earlier this year.
Bonta's case follows a recent victory by New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez against Meta. A jury ruled in March that Meta should pay $375 million in civil penalties for violating New Mexico's unfair practices act. In a subsequent phase, the company was directed to pay an additional $567 million into an abatement fund related to child sexual exploitation allegations.
Bonta indicated that Meta faces continued legal pressure across multiple fronts. He noted that several states already have pending lawsuits against TikTok and expressed concern about YouTube and Snap, describing Meta as merely "first in line" in a broader pursuit of industry-wide solutions to protect children online.
The distinction Bonta drew between damages and civil penalties carries legal significance. While damages compensate victims for harm, civil penalties punish statutory violations and deter future misconduct. By framing the case around penalties and restitution rather than damages, prosecutors emphasize Meta's alleged violation of consumer protection laws rather than seeking compensation for individual child users—a strategy that may face lower evidentiary burdens and different legal precedents.
Related Guide: Read our complete guide →
What This Means
The framing of this case as primarily about statutory penalties rather than damages may influence how other states structure their social media litigation. If successful, the $200 billion penalty figure could establish a precedent for child safety violations that reshapes how Meta and competitors design platforms. The case outcome will likely determine whether regulatory pressure accelerates toward industry-wide design changes or remains focused on individual company enforcement.
Sources: CNBC and other international news outlets.
Disclaimer: This article was produced with AI assistance based on publicly available news sources. While we strive for accuracy, NewsOracle makes no warranty as to the completeness or accuracy of the information. Errors and omissions may occur. Readers should independently verify all information before acting on it. NewsOracle does not intend to defame any individual or organisation and accepts no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content. Content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, medical, or professional advice. All rights reserved. Unauthorised reproduction prohibited.
NewsOracle Editorial
The NewsOracle Tech Desk covers breaking technology news including AI, Apple, Google, Tesla, Meta, OpenAI and product launches.
Latest coverage: Meta
